Early
on in in his main work: A New Critique of
Theoretical Thought, Dooyeweerd writes: “Meaning is the being of all that
has been created and the nature even of our selfhood” (NC I, 4). It is a statement that has intrigued and
confused. Dooyeweerd, however, wastes no
time in explaining that his point is that nothing in reality stands by itself
in its own strength. Anything, any
moment or aspect, any individual or institution in some way expresses something of something
else. In some way it refers beyond itself, and ultimately to
God. Echoing Saint Augustine’s famous
saying “Thou hast made us for thyself, and
our heart is restless until it finds its rest in thee”,
Dooyeweerd described reality as restless.
This
restless referring and expressing suggested to Dooyeweerd the idea of meaning. We might also think of expressions like “the
meaning of life,” or “the meaning of history” to get a sense of what he was
getting at by using this term. It has
something to do with the direction and purpose of things, of all reality. The
idea of meaning is used by Dooyeweerd to point towards a religious dynamic, the movement of creation as
Saint Paul expresses it when writing to the Romans “For from him and through him
and for him are all things. To him be
the glory forever! Amen” (11:36). In
other words, reality expresses the
will of God and refers back to God.
As
with Vollenhoven’s use of the term ‘subject’, so too here it is useful to
contrast what Dooyeweerd is saying with what other philosophers might be
expected to say with the same term. We
would expect philosophers to take the term ‘meaning’ as designating something
about how reality may appear to us.
Reality-in-itself is just so many bits of matter with no inherent
meaning at all. It is only when the
human subject, in the sense rejected by Vollenhoven, confronts it that reality
gets cloaked with meaning, value, even emotion.
Meaning then is a term related to human experience as something quite
separate from reality. On the one side,
the human subject which bestows meaning on things; on the other, the object
meaningless-in-itself.
Dooyeweerd
responds to this picture by saying that it holds no relation to our
experience. Each element of reality is
interconnected with the rest of reality. The way things interrelate in both stable and
changing ways is at the very heart of reality, and the term ‘meaning’
designates this dynamic interconnectedness.
By saying that reality is
meaning, Dooyeweerd rejects the idea that anything could exist in-itself or
could be known of itself. Philosophical
notions like “substance”, “essence” and, “subject” are to be abandoned, or at
least seriously questioned, as they reveal attempts to disconnect some element
of reality both from its relation to other elements of reality and from its
very nature as a dependent creature, from,
through and for God.
We
can now summaries the key Biblical principles that lie at the heart of
reformational philosophy. (1) The
richness of creation demands that philosophy does justice to diversity. (2)
Humans have responsibility primarily realised in tasks that are always limited
in scope. (3) Creational diversity and human responsibility do not have meaning
in themselves but in relation to each other and ultimately to the command to
love God above all else. (4) The interaction between the ordered cosmos and
human responsibility to develop creation’s potential can be helpfully
understood in terms of a dynamic coordination of structure and direction.
Contents
"Philosophical activity is an actual activity; and only at the expense of this very actuality (and then merely in a theoretic concept) can it be abstracted from the thinking self" Herman Dooyeweerd
Saturday, March 24, 2018
Saturday, March 17, 2018
(6) Created reality as ‘subject’
How
does our view of reality as God’s creation translate into reformational philosophy? We have seen that it requires us to recognise
the goodness and the richness of the world around us as well as human
responsibility within creation.
Philosophers like to use words in a precise way, so it would help to
have a word that we can use to refer to the whole of reality that will direct
our analysis according to the biblical principles outlined above. We could just use the word ‘creation’, but
that already carries lots of different meaning and would not help give the
direction needed. Instead, we want a
word that has, or can be given, a fairly precise meaning that brings out
something of philosophical significance from the belief that reality is indeed
God’s creation.
A
number of options can be suggested from the writing of different reformational
philosophers. We shall start with
Vollenhoven’s characterisation of reality as ‘subject’. He writes “That which
is created is completely dependent on the Creator, that is to say, wholly
subject to his sovereign law, Word revelation, and guidance”.
It
is not uncommon in modern philosophy to speak of ‘subject’ or of
‘subjectivity’. Descartes, the so-called
‘father of modern thought’, sought to overcome scepticism and provide a
foundation of certainty in science by starting from the thinking subject. Descartes took the Cogito (‘I think’) as the source or principle of its own activity
which can master the world which it confronts as its object. This ‘turn to subjectivity’ puts freedom and
rationality at the heart of our self-understanding and our view-point on the
‘external world’.
Vollenhoven’s
notion is quite different. As a
creature, a human being must acknowledge that she finds herself called to be
responsible. There is already God’s Word
that called us and the world into existence (Genesis 1), that gives us a task
(Gen 1:28 & 2:15), that invites us to live under God’s blessing,
represented in Genesis 2 by the tree of life, and that warns us against
choosing our own path, represented by the tree of the knowledge of good and
evil. As human beings we find that we
“stand in subjection” to God’s command.
God is King and we are ‘subjects’.
The
term subjectivity, in Vollenhoven, refers not just to us as human beings but to
the whole of creation as called forth by God’s word and as being sustained by
the same word. He takes this ‘being-subject’ of the cosmos as the point of
orientation for philosophy. Anthony Tol notes that "this ‘point of orientation’
characterises the being of created reality not as a theoretical-intellectual is, nor a practical-moral ought, but, in emphasising address and
response, a poetical-religious can"
By
the word of the Lord the heavens were made,
their
starry host by the breath of his mouth.
He
gathers the waters of the sea into jars;
he
puts the deep into storehouses.
Let
all the earth fear the Lord;
let
all the people of the world revere him.
For
he spoke, and it came to be;
he
commanded, and it stood firm. (Psalm 33:6-9)
Sunday, March 11, 2018
(5) Good and evil: Fall and redemption
So far we have perhaps sounded a little too upbeat. That’s
because we haven’t faced the sense of hopelessness we can feel in the face of
gross injustice, we have not heard the cries of those who suffer poverty,
illness or psychological brokenness, we have missed the cry of the lonely, the
abandoned, the violated. We have focused
on the goodness of creation but all too often we see the pollution of
creation. The Bible speaks eloquently of
the groans of creation in its bondage to decay.
Any Christian view of life and the world must wrestle with, while never
fully understanding, the reality of evil and sin.
We must affirm the Biblical view that the goodness of creation is not done away with after sin enters the world. However, it does become more poignant. We can only get close to the full tragedy of evil when we see that it perverts and destroys what was so wonderfully made.
This brings us to our first point: Sin is as wide, though not as deep, as creation. To return to Genesis, we see that sin had its effect on all the relationships humans find themselves in: our relation with each other, with God’s creation and most fundamentally with God (Genesis 3). At the heart of a Christian understanding of life we must place alongside the comprehensive nature of God’s good creation, the comprehensive nature of the fall into sin. This in turn leads us to acknowledge the comprehensive nature of the redemption brought through the life, death and resurrection of Christ.
The comprehensive nature of sin challenges any split between a sacred realm of life and a secular realm just as much as does the comprehensive nature of creation. Sin can be just as present in a prayer meeting as in a board meeting; the church can be just as consumed with power as a government. Therefore, we must remind ourselves that Christ came to “reconcile all things to God, whether on heaven or earth, visible or invisible”. The Gospel is not about God abandoning his creation; it is about turning it around from death to life, from ruin to renewal. Those who are in Christ have died to their old life and their new life covers all human activities in the world, the promise is for a “fullness of life”, not a reduced life of narrowly defined spiritual activities.
A helpful way of setting these biblical truths to work in philosophy is by distinguishing structure and direction. Structure refers to the original intention of God for all areas of life to bring glory to God and blessing to neighbours. It is short-hand for the ordered goodness of creation. Though this structure is certainly obscured and distorted by evil, it remains effective. God is faithful to creation and God’s word upholds its diverse integrity. So when considering how to understand or involve oneself in a cultural task as a Christian, the first guiding principle is to look for and affirm the goodness of God’s order for that activity. We can be sure that the task God has set, when worked on in obedience, brings blessing.
Direction refers to the way that humans choose to respond to God’s call for responsible stewardship and development of creation’s potential. This response can be either in a direction that follows God’s laws, which brings blessing, or a way that ignores God and sets out on a human path which brings curse (this theme of blessing and curse is very prominent in Deuteronomy; in Proverbs it is expressed in terms of wisdom and folly). So a second guiding principle is to discern the ways in which specific cultural tasks have been bent to human desires away from God and thus distorted in ways which bring a curse on us and our neighbours, and to discern the ways in which people have engaged in that task so as to honour God and bring blessings to those nearby. We can draw together the Biblical themes we have been exploring and think Christianly about any subject under the sun by asking these two questions: What is structural or in other words creational? And what is directional?
A constant temptation, especially in philosophy, is to make direction a matter of structure. This happens when we take some aspect of creation as the source of evil or imperfection in the world. As Christians we must reject such views as contradicting the clear teaching of Jesus that evil comes from the human heart. It is not about contamination from some part of created reality (Matthew 15:11).
Once we identify some aspect or area of creation as evil, the follow-up claim is that some other feature of creation is the source of goodness and human hope for salvation. This also is a denial of a fundamental Christian truth: that salvation comes from God. However, as Christians we easily adapt this view through a sacred/secular distinction, which makes certain areas of life the privileged channels of God’s grace and other areas as more susceptible to evil and sin.
Contents
We must affirm the Biblical view that the goodness of creation is not done away with after sin enters the world. However, it does become more poignant. We can only get close to the full tragedy of evil when we see that it perverts and destroys what was so wonderfully made.
This brings us to our first point: Sin is as wide, though not as deep, as creation. To return to Genesis, we see that sin had its effect on all the relationships humans find themselves in: our relation with each other, with God’s creation and most fundamentally with God (Genesis 3). At the heart of a Christian understanding of life we must place alongside the comprehensive nature of God’s good creation, the comprehensive nature of the fall into sin. This in turn leads us to acknowledge the comprehensive nature of the redemption brought through the life, death and resurrection of Christ.
The comprehensive nature of sin challenges any split between a sacred realm of life and a secular realm just as much as does the comprehensive nature of creation. Sin can be just as present in a prayer meeting as in a board meeting; the church can be just as consumed with power as a government. Therefore, we must remind ourselves that Christ came to “reconcile all things to God, whether on heaven or earth, visible or invisible”. The Gospel is not about God abandoning his creation; it is about turning it around from death to life, from ruin to renewal. Those who are in Christ have died to their old life and their new life covers all human activities in the world, the promise is for a “fullness of life”, not a reduced life of narrowly defined spiritual activities.
A helpful way of setting these biblical truths to work in philosophy is by distinguishing structure and direction. Structure refers to the original intention of God for all areas of life to bring glory to God and blessing to neighbours. It is short-hand for the ordered goodness of creation. Though this structure is certainly obscured and distorted by evil, it remains effective. God is faithful to creation and God’s word upholds its diverse integrity. So when considering how to understand or involve oneself in a cultural task as a Christian, the first guiding principle is to look for and affirm the goodness of God’s order for that activity. We can be sure that the task God has set, when worked on in obedience, brings blessing.
Direction refers to the way that humans choose to respond to God’s call for responsible stewardship and development of creation’s potential. This response can be either in a direction that follows God’s laws, which brings blessing, or a way that ignores God and sets out on a human path which brings curse (this theme of blessing and curse is very prominent in Deuteronomy; in Proverbs it is expressed in terms of wisdom and folly). So a second guiding principle is to discern the ways in which specific cultural tasks have been bent to human desires away from God and thus distorted in ways which bring a curse on us and our neighbours, and to discern the ways in which people have engaged in that task so as to honour God and bring blessings to those nearby. We can draw together the Biblical themes we have been exploring and think Christianly about any subject under the sun by asking these two questions: What is structural or in other words creational? And what is directional?
A constant temptation, especially in philosophy, is to make direction a matter of structure. This happens when we take some aspect of creation as the source of evil or imperfection in the world. As Christians we must reject such views as contradicting the clear teaching of Jesus that evil comes from the human heart. It is not about contamination from some part of created reality (Matthew 15:11).
Once we identify some aspect or area of creation as evil, the follow-up claim is that some other feature of creation is the source of goodness and human hope for salvation. This also is a denial of a fundamental Christian truth: that salvation comes from God. However, as Christians we easily adapt this view through a sacred/secular distinction, which makes certain areas of life the privileged channels of God’s grace and other areas as more susceptible to evil and sin.
Contents
Saturday, March 03, 2018
(4) An ordered cosmos
This
world that we live in is not haphazard or arbitrary. God created the world in an ordered and
patterned way. This is quite explicit in
Genesis 1, where it describes God’s separating out light from darkness, sky
from earth and land from sea and creating rich vegetation and varied animals,
each ‘according to their kind’.
The Bible refers to this ordering of creation in many ways: God’s law, ordinances, wisdom and so on. A good example is Psalm 19 which describes the glory of God declared in creation before meditating on God’s law:
The Bible refers to this ordering of creation in many ways: God’s law, ordinances, wisdom and so on. A good example is Psalm 19 which describes the glory of God declared in creation before meditating on God’s law:
7 The law of
the Lord is perfect,
refreshing the soul.
The statutes of the Lord are trustworthy,
making wise the simple.
8 The precepts of the Lord are right,
giving joy to the heart.
The commands of the Lord are radiant,
giving light to the eyes.
9 The fear of the Lord is pure,
enduring forever.
The decrees of the Lord are firm,
and all of them are righteous.
refreshing the soul.
The statutes of the Lord are trustworthy,
making wise the simple.
8 The precepts of the Lord are right,
giving joy to the heart.
The commands of the Lord are radiant,
giving light to the eyes.
9 The fear of the Lord is pure,
enduring forever.
The decrees of the Lord are firm,
and all of them are righteous.
10 They are more
precious than gold,
than much pure gold;
they are sweeter than honey,
than honey from the honeycomb.
11 By them your servant is warned;
in keeping them there is great reward.
than much pure gold;
they are sweeter than honey,
than honey from the honeycomb.
11 By them your servant is warned;
in keeping them there is great reward.
Psalm
19:7-11
Those
familiar with the Bible’s wisdom literature will have less difficulty
understanding what to modern minds appears to be a sudden shift in Psalm 19,
from the way of the sun across the heavens in verse 6, to God’s law revivifying
human life in verse 7. That is because
such literature takes for granted a creation wide perspective on God’s kingship
that is foreign to modern perplexities about how to relate nature and culture.
We should be careful not to project such concerns back into the text.
The
point is that God’s ordinances extend from the natural world through to the
structures of society, to the world of art, to business and commerce. As always
when reading the Bible, we do not look for detailed prescription on how to
live, but for the very bread that sustains our life, the lamp that will light
our path, the power of the gospel to redirect our living before God. We do not
get a detailed theory, but a directing principle that shows us that human
civilization is normed throughout. We
are to open our eyes in faith and see that everywhere there are limits and
proprieties, standards and criteria: in every field of human affairs there are
right and wrong ways of doing things.
There is nothing in human life that does not belong to the created
order. Everything we are and do is
thoroughly creaturely, and requires of us a responsible response to our Creator.
Here
we confront an important issue for Bible-believing Christians. The problem is
that the Bible does not address itself directly to many of the issues that
confront us in modern society. This strengthens the temptation for Christians
to retreat from any effort to engage culture in a distinctively Christian way.
It thus continues the cycle of privatising our beliefs and secularising our
public lives. How then are we to "discover limits" and discern
"right and wrong ways of doing things"?
In
the Old Testament the Israelites were given the Torah, God's laws for being a
holy nation. However, in Exodus 18:15-16 we are told that the people brought
their cases to Moses, and he decided between one person and another and made
known to them “the statutes and instructions of God”. What is interesting is
that the word for “instructions” used here is “torah” in the plural, and this
episode comes before the giving of the law at Mount Sinai. We have the Torah
before the giving of the Torah! We can make sense of this when we look at the
idea of wisdom. Both wisdom and Torah are linked to God’s intent at creation.
So, various psalms speak of the creating word by which God ordered creation in
Genesis 1. These psalms explicitly identify creation by word as creation by
God’s commands, statue, or decree, using these terms as rough equivalents
(Psalms 33:6-9; 119:89-96; 148:5-6). This is the same range of terms used for
the divinely revealed law that Israel is required to obey. Thus there is a
fundamental unity between God’s word in creation and God’s Torah for Israel.
Torah cannot be limited to the written law revealed at Sinai; it holds for the
entire created order. This insight leads Psalm 148:8 to describe even the wind
as obedient to the Creator’s word, while the poet in Psalm 119:91 says to the
Lord God, “All things are your servants.” Law is embedded in creation and
grounds all proper creaturely functioning. A particularly revealing example of
this is given in Isaiah where we are told that wise farmers know how properly
to till the soil and thresh their grain for maximum benefit because “His God
instructs him and teaches him the right way” (28:24-29). Just where we would normally
say that they learned these skills from trial and error, and from being
apprenticed by other, more experienced farmers, we are referred to God's direct
revelation. From these points the
biblical scholar Richard Middleton has concluded that “in principle there is no
difference between wisely discerning God’s will structured into the created
order and obeying God’s revealed word.” This perspective continues in the New
Testament. In numerous places we are exhorted to discern God's will, to work
out our salvation, to practise discerning right from wrong and so on (Romans
12:1-2, Hebrews 5, Philippians 2)
We
can summarise this perspective by saying that God’s Word is first published in
creation, then authoritatively republished in Scripture to guide God’s people
in differing historical circumstances. In the revelation of the law at Sinai,
God simply articulates relevant aspects of God’s creational Word for Israel in
their particular historical context, with their specific needs for moral and
social restoration. God’s Word in creation gives constant direction; the
articulation of this directing Word in changing historical circumstances
requires wisdom as evidenced by the early church in Acts 15.
ContentsSaturday, February 24, 2018
(3) The cultural mandate
Understanding
Christianity in terms of the salvation of our souls has led to a seriously
reduced understanding of the “Great Commission” to make disciples of all
nations. We will only get a fuller
understanding if we go back to the first commission God gave to humans. That is the “cultural commission”, often
referred to as the “cultural mandate”.
In Genesis 1:26-30 and 2:15 God gives Adam and Eve oversight of the whole of creation. We are to act as the stewards of creation both to preserve and to develop. It is this role of authority concerning creation given to humans, both male and female, that is the central meaning of the image of God. We reflect to the world the character of God through continuing God’s work of ordering and developing creation. As with the goodness of creation this is a point that is reaffirmed in many of the Psalms (Psalm 19; 104). It is also central to the picture the New Testament gives us of God's coming kingdom (Matthew 19:28; Luke 22:24-30; Matthew 25:23; 1 Corinthians 6:1-6; Revelation 5:10).
This is a neglected theme, and is of great relevance for understanding the whole-of-life implications of Christianity needed to sustain an authentic Christian philosophy. Therefore, we will spend a little time drawing out three elements of the human task to develop creation:
a. God’s task to humans is creation-wide.
b. Human authority is always limited
c. Our task is always to be seen in the context of
service
The
first point is foundational. To all
those who would say that the primary task of a Christian is to evangelise, and
that everything else is of secondary or even of no importance, it should be
pointed out that evangelism has no meaning unless it is a discipleship of every
nation in the Gospel of Christ. It is
worth remembering that the Gospel of Jesus was the announcement of the coming
kingdom (Mark 1:15, Matthew 4:17), that is the rule of God over all things, for
which we are taught to pray (Matthew 6:10, Luke 11:2). Everything is to be done to the glory of God
and for the blessing of one’s neighbour as affirmed in Jesus’ summary of the
law (Matthew 22:34-40). Nothing can be excluded from this, from the making of
clothes to farming, governing to refuse collection, artistic crafts to
commerce. Each of these tasks can be engaged in so as to invite God’s kingdom
to come or so as to take a share of God’s inheritance while refusing to
recognise him as Father. Anything less than this is a reduction of the Gospel.
An
implication of this is that we are to develop creation and its great
potential. Our task involves an opening
up of the richness of creation bringing forth new possibilities. This means that historical development and
change is a natural and good part of God’s purposes for human life. Historical change can often be guided by a
spirit of human rebellion against God, as made clear at the tower of Babel.
Nevertheless, as Christians we should not be reactionary in our evaluation of
historical change.
Our
freedom to get involved in cultural activities is creation wide. However, there is also an important sense of
limitation. We do not own the world,
“the earth is the Lord’s and everything in it”. Therefore, our cultural activities and social roles always take on a limited form
in contrast to God’s unlimited sovereignty.
These activities and roles have the quality of tasks and
responsibilities we hold before God. For
example: to maintain justice and order in public life, to bring children into
the world, to worship God and proclaim the message of salvation, to pass on the
wisdom of one generation to the next, to produce goods for human use and
enjoyment.
Each of these tasks should be seen as a genuine Christian vocation. When we pray; “your will be done here on earth as it is in heaven”, we should be reminded of our own role in fulfilling these tasks, and others as well, all in the service of God. The Lord’s Prayer must be prayed from within the work office, within the board meeting, within the courtroom. God’s Will is to be done in each and every situation.
We are touching here on a basic perspective on social institutions that is quite different from that commonly held today. We shall explore this more later on. For now, it is enough to say that in understanding a school, or a business, a government or hospital as something formed in response to God-given tasks means that we must reject the view that such institution are basically arbitrary structures that exist to serve the interests and goals of the individuals that make them up.
Within the framework of limited responsibility before God and for the blessing of our neighbour we can outline a different approach. God appoints humans to perform certain tasks that are communal in character. Humans respond through the formation of different social organizations. So we have marriages, families, businesses, churches, governing authorities, schools and so on. Each exists by responding to distinct cultural tasks. These tasks are neither all-encompassing nor individualistic; they are limited and communal tasks. We can evaluate institutions on the basis of their openness to God and others and on the basis of their distinctive tasks. We can also be critical when one particular task starts to dominate and usurp or undermine the role of other societal tasks. In such a situation we can see the real danger of a move away from recognising God’s total authority over human culture and towards an assertion of human authority based in one of the social spheres.
The
final point is that human cultural activity is designed to be honouring to God,
a blessing to those it affects and an act of stewardly love to the rest of
creation. Dooyeweerd summarised the
cultural mandate by saying that God created humans as rulers of creation so that the powers and potentials which God has enclosed within creation are to be disclosed by men and women in their
service of love to God and neighbour.
This will have a radical impact on the way we think about the role of an
artist or the place of a business enterprise in society, the task of national
governments and the role of universities, and indeed about the vital task of
philosophy.
Friday, February 16, 2018
(2) Philosophy and Worldview
Philosophy
must start somewhere and the aim of reformational philosophy is to be a
philosophy that is in line with scripture. This means it is important to
say something about the world and life vision that finds its inspiration in the
Bible. To do this we shall make some
comments about the key Biblical themes of creation, fall and redemption with
particular emphasis on the first since, as we have already indicated, that is
what gives context to philosophical activity.
Creation
includes everything that is not God.
There are three points about creation that are relevant in this context
which will be explored in this and the following sections:
1. Creation is good.
2. The human task is to develop creation.
3. Creation is ordered (given structure) by God
The
Bible’s story of creation is described in terms of God commanding by his Word
and creation responding in obedience.
After each response God affirms what he has made. And we see that the whole of creation, in all
its rich diversity is considered very good.
We should be careful not to equate this goodness with other-worldly
notions of perfection, or think of goodness only in relations to our own
desires. Creation is set up to fulfil
the purposes given to it by God; that is what is central. Creation is God’s kingdom (Psalm 24); it
reveals his will (Psalm 19); and should be received with thanksgiving (1
Timothy 4:4)
To
believe in the God who has revealed Himself in the Bible is to understand
ourselves and the world we live in as God’s world; we were made to be at home
in this world. We are part of God’s good creation and thus are part of His
ongoing purposes. Life is of one piece
and the fundamental question for the Christian is to what extent one’s life is
a walk of obedience to God. That
following Christ has implications for the whole of life is often resisted by
Christians and it is worth considering why this is. In reformational philosophy this resistance
is attributed to a basic “dualism” that underlies it, though it is worth noting
that today there may be a lot of emphasis given to “integrating” the two realms
or spheres that form this dualism. The
basic idea is that life can be separated into a natural and a supernatural realm. The natural realm is constituted by the
common world in which all people live whether they are Christian or not. Here people build homes for themselves, live
together in society, develop science and pursue various social and personal
goals without much concern for “religious” issues. It is a realm that is largely neutral with
regard to religion and, in that sense, is sometimes described as
“secular”. The supernatural realm is
then that realm of life that is unique to Christian experience. It is primarily found in the church community
and involves distinctive activities like worship, prayer, Bible reading and
some specific moral teachings. This
sphere is directly affected by religion in the sense that God’s grace brings an
individual into this sphere, or adds this to one’s common life. So, as well as being a car mechanic and
football fan you become someone who prays, reads the Bible and attends church.
It
is important to see that this is a very persuasive position. It is a “ground motive” that affects us all
such that it often acts like ‘common sense’ and can be very difficult to
resist. We need to see what’s wrong with
this view at its heart. The key is to
see that our whole life belongs to God. There is no sphere of our existence
that can be hidden from God or that can be kept back from the claim of Christ’s
Lordship. So the problem with this view
is that it undermines the integrity of our religious situation. The whole of reality is created, sustained,
and ordered by God; it is comprehensively distorted, though not destroyed, by
the fall; and the whole of reality is taken up in God’s redemptive work through
history to reconcile all things to himself.
The great Dutch theologian Herman Bavinck summarised this stance simply
like this: “God the father has reconciled His created but fallen world through
the death of His Son, and renews it into a Kingdom of God by His Spirit.” What this means is that any attempt to divide reality up
into a 'secular' or 'natural' sphere and a 'spiritual' or 'supernatural' sphere
undermines the comprehensiveness of the central biblical categories of
creation, fall and redemption.
We
must therefore resist any view that sees salvation as taking us out of this
world, and so sees our destination as a spiritual realm beyond this world. Such a view finds no support from the Bible.
However it does hold a striking resemblance to certain pagan Greek ideas of the
world of matter as evil, or a principle of imperfection, and of a non-physical
soul as our true self which is trapped in the body and longs for its release
into a purely spiritual world. One
important source of these ideas has been Plato’s dialogue the Phaedo, which
has unfortunately been more influential in many Christians’ understanding of
spirituality and eternal life than 1 Corinthians 15, as the New Testament
scholar Oscar Cullmann once noted. This Greek inspired view has both minimised
the value of our earthly lives and cut off whole chunks of our life from the
renewing power of the Gospel. While it
is true that most Christians would reject the more extreme forms of this view
it is still common for Christians to think of their life in terms of sacred and
secular and so find it strange that the Gospel is relevant to the whole of
life. The effect of this deep lying dualism is to deny the lordship of Christ
for the greater part of our life! It
leads us to assume that work and play, food and drink, business and politics,
art and entertainment are somehow outside of our Christian calling.
This
is really important. When the
comprehensive character of creation is taken out of a Christian view, when we
start with a reduced Christian faith that covers only Sunday service and
private Bible study, then we cut out any relevance the Christian faith can have
for life, and in doing so we condemn Christianity to irrelevance. A Christian philosophy cannot solve these
problems, indeed it will suffer from them. Seeing how such a philosophy can
give distinctive insight and direction in the different sectors of life can,
however, play its part in encouraging a more wholehearted Christian life.
Saturday, February 10, 2018
(1) Philosophy and the richness of creation (continued)
So, the example of a children's party, a fairly ordinary and
practical event which can provide our first step towards a philosophical
exploration of the richness of creation. To the child, their birthday
party is a very simple thing; it means presents, friends, food and fun. For the
poor parents, however, there is much more going on! First, there will be the decision as to who,
and how many, will be invited. Invitations will need to be designed and sent
out. Then, where to hold the party; a space is needed big enough to contain the
number of children invited. Since the children will be doing a lot of running
around the space will need to be big! How big, and what entertainment to put on,
old-fashioned party games, or a hired magician, will depend in part on what the
parents view as a reasonable cost for such a party. However, there will also be
social expectations, perhaps very high and pressuring, that the parents will
feel more keenly than the children. With games come prizes; how will they be
distributed, and what happens when boisterous play upsets one of the little
guests? Food is also an important component, and thought will need to go into
when this is given to the children and how they might be encouraged to eat some
healthy food rather than going straight for the crisps and cake! The timing for
what happens at the party may also be important; for how long will each
activity hold the attention of the kids; when is the appropriate time to bring
in the cake and sing happy birthday?
Table 1(adapted from Arthur Jones 1998, 18-19)
In
reformational philosophy it is standard to give expression to the richness of
creation by recognising that in reality we experience a number of different
dimensions or ‘aspects’. Much more will
be said about these later; for now we start by listing the 15 ‘modal aspects’
that, give or take a few, all reformational philosophers have come to
recognise. Questions have been added to
help see how recognising these aspects will help us explore the variety of ways
created things can function.
Table 1(adapted from Arthur Jones 1998, 18-19)
Aspects
|
Key Questions
|
Numerical
|
How
many?
|
Spatial
|
How
big?
|
Movement
|
How
fast?
|
Energy
|
How
reactive?
|
Biotic
|
How
productive?
|
Psychic/sensitive
|
How
stimulating?
|
Analytic
|
How
intelligible?
|
Historical
|
How
creative/skilful?
|
Aesthetic
|
How
imaginative?
|
Lingual
|
How
clear?
|
Social
|
How
sociable?
|
Economic
|
How
valuable?
|
Jural
|
How
just?
|
Ethical
|
How
loving?
|
Faith
|
How
trustworthy?
|
Have
a look back at what was said about planning a child’s birthday party. With a bit of effort you should be able to
see that most, if not all, of the 15 aspects are present. You may want to try and imagine a children’s
party that completely avoids one of the aspects. In trying this you may be surprised at how
hard it actually is.
So
we now have an example of recognising the richness of creation. Its practical use is that a good children’s
party will need to consider all of these factors and ensure that they are all
in order. However, it also raises a
problem. What looked simple now looks
too complicated and we might wonder what has happened to the simplicity of
having fun while celebrating a child’s birthday. This problem is actually a very significant
and long-standing philosophical one: the problem of unity and diversity.
Without
trying to solve this philosophical problem right now, we can say that it is
common for one aspect to take the lead, so to speak, in specific contexts. In the context of a children’s party it is
the social element of friends having fun together and marking an important
point in a child’s life. This means that the social element is the leading
aspect which should provide focus for the parents in their planning and all the
other elements that are part of the party should serve this one. If the parents considered only the health and
safety of the children, or only worried about getting all the numbers right,
then the chance of a good birthday party would be significantly reduced.
You
might like to try this exercise on other planned events, projects or
communities you are involved in. Do you discover that there are always many
factors involved in a successful outcome even if many of these seem minor and
often go unnoticed? Have you experienced events where the little things became
so important that the main purpose was lost sight of?
Tuesday, February 06, 2018
What's the use of a Christain philosophy?
I mentioned in my last post that we should be cautious about the
demand for usefulness. If the task is a genuine one, and I believe seeking to
give a coherent theoretical account of the diversity of God's creation is
such a task, then it will bear fruit. It may not be immediate and
obvious, but we can expect some contribution to human flourishing. Now I would
suggest that if an explicitly Christian philosophy, developed before the advent
of digital computers, was able to bring insight into the study of information
systems, then that would suggest that it had something worthwhile to it. If this
philosophy could be presented in a way that acknowledged it's rootedness in the
Christian faith, and yet could appeal to a wide audience so that a leading academic
publisher was willing to print it, then we should sit up and take some notice.
Andrew Basden has taken Herman Dooyeweerd's philosophy and done just that. See his latest book Foundations of Information Systems.
Steve Bishop has a great two part interview with Andrew. Here's a snippet:
I want to leave behind a means by which people can understand Dooyeweerd and his usefulness. That is primarily why I wrote the book. It explains Dooyeweerd's philosophy to a degree that I think people would be able to work from even if I wrote nothing more, and it discusses how Dooyeweerd's philosophy can do two things in each of five areas. One is to provide a foundational understanding of each area. The other is to engage with discourses in the area - over 50 of them. I don't want to reject or replace the ideas on which each discourse centres, but to affirm what is valid, critique the underlying presuppositions, and enrich the ideas, all using Dooyeweerd and the foundational understanding I have constructed.
Read the interview here:

Saturday, February 03, 2018
(1) Philosophy and the richness of creation
“And
it was good” said God concerning creation six times before concluding on the
seventh occasion that it was very
good. Any philosophy that aims to honour
God will have to reckon with the goodness of creation. As Vollenhoven has it, Reformational
philosophy takes creation, the cosmos as distinct from God, as its focus. This is an important difference from other
philosophical approaches. One
consequence of this difference is that we honour God by doing justice to the
richness of creation. Much philosophy
finds its motivation in trying to explain the whole of reality in terms of a
very limited range of features. Today
materialism is very popular. According
to this view everything that exists is just physical stuff arranged in a
variety of complex ways. Materialism may
well be very ‘open’ to new evidence and to the further progress of science.
However, it is still a ‘closed system’ in the terms of the quote from
Vollenhoven since it encloses the richness of creation in only one of its
dimensions or aspect (the material), and therefore shuts itself off from the
many other dimensions of creation.
An emphasis on doing justice to the richness of creation may cause a positive reaction. “Good,” some might say, “a philosophy that affirms God’s world in all its variety. A Christian philosophy that gives a ‘yes’ to being fully human, a Christian philosophy that is not restrictive of human activity out of fear of being too worldly”. That is a reaction we hope for since we can only be truly human by being in Christ and so being reconciled to God. Christ came that we should have life, and life in all its fullness.
However, it is quite possible that this talk about the richness of creation might provoke a different reaction. Others may have had some good experience of philosophy, but mixed in with more disheartening experiences. Philosophy can be difficult and complicated, full of strange words and abstract distinctions. Such people may well have read some reformational philosophy and found this to be their experience. “All this talk of the richness of creation,” they object, “is it not just an excuse to be over complicated? And after all, what is the practical use of all this theory? Should we as Christians really spend so much time on obscure philosophy?”
The requirement that philosophy should enrich our lives is a valid one, though we need also to be careful of closing things down by demanding that something have an immediate and obvious practical use. Leaving that aside for now, since we can agree that the objection does have its validity, let us consider an example of what doing justice to the richness of creation might look like. Before continuing consider the planning of an event, choose something familiar to you, in my next post I’ll reflect on planning a child’s birthday party. What things would you need to consider?
An emphasis on doing justice to the richness of creation may cause a positive reaction. “Good,” some might say, “a philosophy that affirms God’s world in all its variety. A Christian philosophy that gives a ‘yes’ to being fully human, a Christian philosophy that is not restrictive of human activity out of fear of being too worldly”. That is a reaction we hope for since we can only be truly human by being in Christ and so being reconciled to God. Christ came that we should have life, and life in all its fullness.
However, it is quite possible that this talk about the richness of creation might provoke a different reaction. Others may have had some good experience of philosophy, but mixed in with more disheartening experiences. Philosophy can be difficult and complicated, full of strange words and abstract distinctions. Such people may well have read some reformational philosophy and found this to be their experience. “All this talk of the richness of creation,” they object, “is it not just an excuse to be over complicated? And after all, what is the practical use of all this theory? Should we as Christians really spend so much time on obscure philosophy?”
The requirement that philosophy should enrich our lives is a valid one, though we need also to be careful of closing things down by demanding that something have an immediate and obvious practical use. Leaving that aside for now, since we can agree that the objection does have its validity, let us consider an example of what doing justice to the richness of creation might look like. Before continuing consider the planning of an event, choose something familiar to you, in my next post I’ll reflect on planning a child’s birthday party. What things would you need to consider?
Sunday, January 28, 2018
The Task of Philosophy
Even though its task is limited, the philosophy that keeps the line between God and cosmos in mind need not be in want of work. For a philosopher who believes that God created the cosmos proceeds every time again from the presupposition that the wealth in that which is created will be much greater than has been ascertained up to that time. For that reason, such a philosopher can never say, “I am ready, look here, a closed system.” On the contrary, her result, though acquired systematically, is always a provisional one, for she remains filled with expectation, attuned to new surprises that will no doubt complement the main conception that agrees with belief, yet will time and again supplement and usually alter earlier findings.
Vollenhoven Introduction
to Philosophy
The provisional title for my introduction is Tasks and
Cosmos. The above quote from Vollenhoven gives a good indication why.
Central to reformational philosophy is an aversion to speculation, and a
down-to-earth focus on the world we live in. This cosmos, created by God, is
good and richer, more varied and surprising than any philosophy has so far been
able to fathom. A Christian philosophy must be "attuned to new
surprises". The focus of philosophy is this cosmos in its
interrelated diversity. But secondly the emphasis is on the notion of tasks.
First of all the task of philosophy itself. This though is just one of many
possible tasks that can be taken up by us creatures made in God's image.
Reformational philosophy starts out from a notion that every truly human task is
good and limited. Even though such tasks are limited, as Vollenhoven points
out, they are given for human flourishing and provide ample work in honouring
God and serving our neighbours.
Saturday, January 27, 2018
Contents for introduction to reformational philosophy
Here is the plan for the first three chapters. There may be changes as it develops and takes shape. I will add links back to here to help navigation through the sections.
Introduction
What
is philosophy?
(10) Rational thinking
(12) No Archimedean point
Further reading
Understanding the cosmos
Understanding the cosmos
(20) What is Time?
(24) Sensory perception
(26) Idionomy
(27) Non-human subjects
(28) Encapsis
(29) Limits of theory
(35) Faith and religion
(36) Faith and theology
(37) Philosophy andGod
Saturday, January 20, 2018
An Introduction to Reformational Philosophy
I have been reading reformational philosophy now for over twenty years. It has had a profound impact on my thinking and continues to inspire me. It now seems appropriate to offer an introduction to this tradition of serious Christian thinking in the hope of encouraging others to benefit from its many insights. For those not familiar with reformational philosophy it can be identified as a
little known Christian approach to philosophy pioneered by two Dutch
philosophers in the first half of the 20th century. Herman Dooyeweerd (1894-1977) and Dirk Th.
Vollenhoven (1892-1978) were professors at the Free University in Amsterdam
founded by the great Dutch theologian and statesman Abraham Kuyper (1837-1920)
in 1880 as a Christian university founded on “reformed principles”. The huge potential of this philosophy to be a
blessing to Christians and their neighbours has yet to be fulfilled. In part this is due to the complexity of many
of the books produced by this philosophical movement, and partly because of the
different way of thinking it promotes. It is my hope that in trying to explain
some of its ideas and principles in a concise and clear way, a small contribution
may be made to making reformational philosophy better known and appreciated.
This introduction is a work in progress with the plan to set it out across four
chapters, each containing short digestible sections. The first two chapters are
short and introductory, looking first at the worldview background, and, next, at the nature and task of philosophy. The
final two chapters will be much longer and form the main exposition of
reformational philosophy, first focusing on “understanding the cosmos”, and second on “Understanding our Tasks”.
Previous
introductions to reformational philosophy have tended either to focus on one
philosopher, usually Herman Dooyeweerd, or to introduce the author’s own
version of reformational philosophy. Concerning the first it must be said that
Dooyeweerd's writing style has not proved attractive to
non-philosophers and philosophers trained in the analytic tradition. In addition,
there are many other who are worthy of treatment
in their own right. My aim then has been to try and bring together the key
insights and contributions from as wide a range of the tradition as I could, in
the hope that this will help newcomers to get a good taste of the potential of
reformational philosophy as a living tradition. On the second point, while the
selection and presentation cannot help but be personal, I have aimed to stay in
the mainstream of reformational philosophy and to avoid deliberate innovation or
idiosyncrasy. The further reading
sections are an integral part of this introduction as they attempt to document
my sources, but also act as an invitation to discover more of the reformational
tradition.
Contents
Contents
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)